Total recall in the SCAMP cohort: Validation of self-reported mobile phone use in the smartphone era

Authors: Mireku MO, Mueller W, Fleming C, Chang I, Dumontheil I, Thomas MSC, Eeftens M, Elliott P, Röösli M, Toledano MB

Year: 2017 Oct 30

Category: Epidemiology

Journal: Environ Res

DOI: 10.1016/j.envres.2017.10.034

URL: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29096315

Abstract

Overview

The study investigates the reliability of self-reported mobile phone use among adolescents for accurate exposure assessment in epidemiological research, contrasting these data with mobile operator traffic data.

Findings

  • Comparison between self-reported mobile phone data and actual traffic data from mobile operators amongst adolescents aged 11-12 years.
  • Assessment based on call frequency, cumulative call time, and text messages using Cohen's weighted Kappa statistics.
  • Highest agreement observed in the duration spent talking on mobile phones per day during weekdays (38.9%) and weekends (29.4%).
  • Differential agreement noted across genders and socioeconomic groups with little variations.
  • Specificity and sensitivity analysis demonstrated that the questionnaire could distinguish between high and low mobile phone users effectively, especially in call frequency during weekdays.

Conclusion

Despite discrepancies between self-reported and operator-collected data, self-reported measures are deemed sufficient for identifying different levels of mobile phone use among adolescents. The study underscores the importance of considering Wi-Fi over mobile networks in exposure assessments.

← Back to Stats