Distinguishing Polemic From Commentary in Science: Some Guidelines Illustrated With the Case of Sage and Burgio (2017)

Authors: Grimes DR, Bishop DV

Year: 2017 Dec 21

Category: Science Communication

Journal: Child Dev

DOI: 10.1111/cdev.13013

URL: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29266222

Abstract

Abstract Summary

Overview

Exposure to nonionizing radiation from wireless communication continues to be a heavily debated issue within public discourse.

Findings

  • Despite strong scientific consensus indicating the safety of microwave and radio frequencies, public concerns persist.
  • A recent publication in Child Development has exacerbated fears by linking nonionizing radiation to various health conditions such as autism and cancer.

Conclusion

This commentary addresses why such claims lack scientific backing and cautions against lending them undue credibility. It serves as a guide to identify questionable scientific assertions, aimed at assisting authors, reviewers, and editors.

← Back to Stats