|
| |
DTI and
Which? At Odds Over Phone Safety
The Register
Journalist: Lucy Sherriff
August 08, 2000
Consumers have
been left without a clue - should they go hands-6.00 or clamp their mobile phone
to their ear?
Research published by the government today indicates that hands-6.00 mobile
phone kits are safe to use. These new findings appear to totally contradict a
recent report from Which? the consumers association magazine.
However, the two opposing views could be a result of nothing more than a dispute
over methodology. One group of researchers measured the amount of radiation
emitted by the phones, while the other measured radiation absorbed by the body,
while using the phone.
The Consumers Association (CA) said that it was not convinced that specific
absorption of radiation (SAR) test was reliable or safe. Helen Parker, the
editor of Which? said: "We stand by our original test results published
earlier this year. We think there are problems with current SAR testing for
Hands Free kits and we are carrying out more research into this area."
So who is to be believed? A spokeswoman for the DTI said that it was not the
department's place to comment on other people's research, and that its findings
showed all the absorption levels were within the safe parameters set by the
National Radiological Protection Board.
Meanwhile, the
CA says that there is no standard SAR test, and that results vary widely from
laboratory to laboratory. The DTI says that since this experiment compared SAR
levels without and then with a Hands Free kit in the same lab, the results are
indeed reliable.
It is difficult to know who to trust since both groups have strong motives to
keep the debate running. The CA wants to sell more reports and the government
stands to make a handsome wedge from the sale of mobile phone licences.
There is more information available than ever before on the safety of mobile
phones, but it is often contradictory, and little help to the end users who need
to make the risk assessment for themselves.
| |
"In God We
Trust" Site Prayer "
llphone radiation
http://rfsafe.com/index.php
|
